|
||
|
||
A slogan is a promise until the registry writes its own name on the deed.
For five years one phrase has done the work that no argument could do: “IP for Africa”.
It is a good phrase. I agree with it.
Addresses for the networks that serve Africans. Who could object?
The trouble is not the phrase. The trouble is the direction in which it is read.
Read forwards, it is a promise a registry makes to its customers: you will get the addresses you need, and the ones you run on are yours.
AFRINIC’s new transfer policy reads it backwards.
Africa for AFRINIC.
Listen to how the claim is built.
Because we are the registry for Africa, the addresses we register are Africa’s.
Because they are Africa’s, they must stay in Africa.
Because they must stay, you may not leave with them.
Because you may not leave, you answer to us.
And because we are the only registry here, there is no one else to answer to.
Each step is in AFRINIC’s own papers. The policy it ratified on 4 February 2026 marks every address from its pool “Regional”. 2 Its summary of the policy says: “AFRINIC-issued IPv4 cannot be transferred out of the region”. 1 Its staff assessment says what follows for the member: “AFRINIC will not lose its current resource members to other RIRs in outgoing transfers. This proposal will therefore have a minimal financial impact on AFRINIC’s revenue.” 2 The proposal makes number resources “non-transferable unless AFRINIC has expressly and in writing approved a request for transfer”. 2 And the summary lists the result among the benefits: “Strengthens AFRINIC’s governance mandate in managing Internet number resources within the African region.” 1
Each step sounds like stewardship.
Together they are a land claim made by a filing clerk.
An IP address is a number.
It has no soil, no flag and no passport.
It works for one reason: every network in the world accepts that one network uses it and no other.
The numbers AFRINIC registers did not come out of African ground. AFRINIC says so itself: “Internet Number Resources are allocated to AFRINIC and the four other RIRs by Public Technical Identifiers (PTI), the organisation responsible for coordinating the Internet’s unique identifiers.” 3
AFRINIC is a counter in a global system.
So there are no “African IP addresses” to take. There are addresses registered at the counter that serves Africa. A network that registers at that counter has taken nothing from Africa.
The Internet was born as one network.
In 1992 the guidelines that set out the plan for regional registries, RFC 1366, gave the reason plainly: registries “located in distinct geographic areas may be better able to serve the local community in terms of language and local customs”. They also asked for “just a single regional registry per geographical region”, for “efficient and fair sub-allocation of the address space”. 4
So the design gave us two things: a convenience and a monopoly.
It did not give anyone a continent.
Karl Auerbach, an early Internet engineer, described on this site his last conversation with Jon Postel. In his recollection the regions were drawn “rather arbitrarily” in places, Africa among them, and he came away, as he believes Postel did, thinking the registries “would have been better formed as temporary organizations that could be created, removed, aggregated, or split” as the network changed. 5
A help desk was assigned a district.
It has since declared the district its estate.
Ownership needs an owner.
Political ownership belongs to a people: those who share a culture, a history and an identity, and a government that answers for them.
A continent is a shape on a map.
What do Cairo, Kinshasa and Cape Town share, beyond that map?
Not a language. Not a legal system. Not a history. Not a government.
Africa is fifty-four countries, and each owns what its own law says it owns.
“Africa’s IP addresses” would need an owner called Africa.
There is none.
There is only a private company in Mauritius, with eight elected seats on its board, volunteering for the part.
The serious argument for the lock is fairness. The authors of the policy make it themselves: AFRINIC “manages only 7.23 /8s with a very low ratio of IPv4 addresses per Internet user”, so addresses should come in “without necessarily depleting AFRINIC’s slim amount of IPv4 addresses by transferring space out of the region”. 2 Scarce addresses, handed out by need and kept inside the region, are supposed to protect the weaker network from the richer buyer.
Test it against the record.
The registries have allocated by need for thirty years. RFC 7020 states the rule: allocations “must be made in accordance with the operational needs of those running the networks”. 6 A network shows more need when it already has more capital, more equipment and more customers. The rule reads the scale a network already has and returns addresses in proportion. The networks registered through AFRINIC hold 3.15% of the world’s delegated IPv4. Inside AFRINIC’s region, the networks of three countries hold about 55% of what is delegated across its sovereign states, and those of the bottom thirty hold 2.74%. 7
Need-based allocation in an unequal world does not neutralise inequality. It codifies it.
A lock does no better. It does not add one address. It makes every block it covers worth less, as a sale and as security for a loan, than the same block registered anywhere else. A region does not become richer because the assets of its networks cannot leave. 8
A provider that locks the door is not protecting Africa. By its own assessment, it is keeping its members.
The addresses that did go missing from AFRINIC’s pool did not leave through any transfer.
In January 2021 AFRINIC published its own audit. It found 2,371,584 IPv4 addresses “misappropriated from AFRINIC’s pool of resources and attributed to organisations without justification”, after “a former employee was found to have misappropriated IP number resources”. 9
Nothing was taken from Africa by the networks that registered there.
What went missing went missing in the registry.
If you are the only provider in town, the conclusion should run the other way.
You owe more, not less.
AFRINIC’s contract goes the other way. Every network that registers with it signs the Registration Service Agreement. The member receives “an exclusive right of use”, “within the ambit of the ‘need’ which it has justified in its application and for no other purpose”. It must acknowledge that the number resources “are not property (real, personal or intellectual)”. If the agreement ends, “AFRINIC will immediately revoke the number resources and otherwise cease providing the services without incurring any liability whatsoever”. Liability under the agreement is capped at six months of fees or 100 US dollars, whichever is greater. 10
That is AFRINIC’s contract. I challenge it.
AFRINIC wrote the clause, in its own standard form, and a network in its region has no other registry to go to. Sign it, or have no addresses of your own. Why should the organisation that keeps the record decide whether its customers own what is recorded in it?
I say the network is the owner in substance. It holds the addresses lawfully, runs on them, finances them and carries the whole loss if they are taken away. The registry does none of that. I made the full argument here in March. 11
The contract does not show that the network owns nothing. It shows who was holding the pen.
The land registry records every title deed. The deeds belong to the owners. It owns none of the land.
The office that issues number plates does not own the cars, or decide where they may be driven.
The telephone directory has never claimed the telephones.
Each of them is the only one of its kind where it works.
None has concluded that the district is therefore its property.
Only here does the clerk say the ledger makes him the landlord.
AFRINIC has gone furthest, but all five Regional Internet Registries are built the same way: one per region, each keeping the record of holdings that are bought, sold, leased and financed every day.
What a registry must do to keep that record is short. It must stop the same number being registered twice. It must keep an accurate record of who holds what. It must check that the party transferring a holding is the party on record. RFC 7020 itself puts routing “outside the scope of the Internet Numbers Registry System”. 6 The rest is habit.
A registry may verify that a transfer does not break the Internet. It may not decide whether the transfer deserves to exist.
And the record must be able to outlive the record-keeper. The registries are revising ICP-2, the document under which they are recognised, to add criteria for derecognising a registry that fails. 12 A registry can lose its recognition. Its networks still have to run. A network that can take its addresses to another registry survives. A network that cannot is the collateral.
Monopoly does not create ownership. Monopoly creates duty.
So I keep the slogan.
IP for Africa means that a network in Lagos, Bujumbura or Maseru owns the addresses it runs on.
It holds them, uses them wherever its customers are, takes them to another registry if it chooses, and sells its services to the world.
The deed is the network’s. The registry records it.
It means a vote in the registry that serves it.
It means a court to turn to when that registry overreaches.
It means the freedom to leave.
That is IP for Africa.
I am for it.
A registry is not a continent.
The deed belongs to the network, not to the registry.
A monopoly is not a mandate.
IP for Africa.
Not Africa for AFRINIC.
Disclosure: I do not write this from a distance. My company, Cloud Innovation Ltd, registered its addresses through AFRINIC and has been in litigation with AFRINIC since 2021. Every AFRINIC document quoted above was published by AFRINIC. This is the CircleID edition of my Note 78.
Sponsored byIPv4.Global
Sponsored byCSC
Sponsored byRadix
Sponsored byDNIB.com
Sponsored byVerisign
Sponsored byWhoisXML API
Sponsored byVerisign