|
I recently reviewed Trump’s Cuban policy speech and its implications for the Internet. The speech was accompanied by a national security memorandum on strengthening US-Cuba policy, which was sent to the Vice President, Cabinet Secretaries, and heads of various departments.
The first thing that struck me about the memorandum was that it was a “national security” memorandum. Does Trump think Cuba poses a threat to our national security? And how does his policy improve the situation? That is a topic for another discussion, but what does the memorandum say about the Internet?
PRESIDENTIAL MEMORANDA / June 16, 2017 – Trump orders the Secretary of State to create a Cuban Internet task force.The memorandum addresses the Internet in its purpose, policy and implementation sections.
The purpose section states that in Cuba “the right to speak freely, including through access to the internet, is denied, and there is no free press.” One of the purposes of the memorandum is to restore the right to speak freely on the Internet. The Cuban government censors and sometimes punishes dissent and uses the Internet for propaganda, but it is not clear that Trump’s policy and attitude will improve the situation. Furthermore, freedom of speech online is often abused and it is ironic that Trump should lecture anyone on this issue.
In the policy section, Trump says he will “amplify efforts to support the Cuban people through the expansion of Internet services, free press, free enterprise, free association, and lawful travel.” This sounds good, but, at best, it is inconsistent with the policy he outlined last month in Saudi Arabia when he promised that “America will not seek to impose our way of life on others but to outstretch our hands in the spirit of cooperation and trust.” At worst, he could be considering actions like the failed smuggling of satellite equipment into Cuba, Zunzuneo or the Alan Gross affair.
The implementation section says he will “support the expansion of direct telecommunications and Internet access for the Cuban people” by having the Secretary of State convene
a task force, composed of relevant departments and agencies, including the Office of Cuba Broadcasting, and appropriate non-governmental organizations and private-sector entities, to examine the technological challenges and opportunities for expanding internet access in Cuba, including through Federal Government support of programs and activities that encourage freedom of expression through independent media and internet freedom so that the Cuban people can enjoy the free and unregulated flow of information
I contacted the State Department to see if they could tell me more about the task force, but they offered no details at this time. I’ll follow up on this.
I cannot end this post without commenting on the writing style of the memorandum. It is written in the first person, implying that Trump actually wrote it. I am sure it was drafted and revised by staff, but gratuitous adjectives as in “dissidents and peaceful protesters are arbitrarily detained and held in terrible prison conditions,” sounded Trumpian to me and the call for the establishment of a task force, quoted above, reminded me of James Joyce. I also found the organization confusing in places. Some policies seemed more like goals, and one of them is to “not reinstate the ‘Wet Foot, Dry Foot’ policy.” One wonders why he did not also vow not to reinstate limits on the value of rum and cigars travelers are allowed to bring back from Cuba.
Sponsored byIPv4.Global
Sponsored byCSC
Sponsored byRadix
Sponsored byWhoisXML API
Sponsored byVerisign
Sponsored byVerisign
Sponsored byDNIB.com